The GuideStar Blog retired September 9, 2019. We invite you to visit its replacement, the Candid Blog. You’re also welcome to browse or search the GuideStar Blog archives. Onward!

GuideStar Blog

Who Will Lead Your Fundraising Campaign?

Reprinted from Contributions Magazine

Recruiting quality campaign leadership is critical to the success of your fundraising campaign. If your board is so strong that you don't need to recruit additional leaders to reach your goal, then your goal is probably too low! Campaigns give community leaders a chance to be seen as involved in the community, without committing the time and effort it takes to be a board member.

How do you identify great campaign leaders? The first key is not to get caught up in the "exclusive" argument. Some campaigns try to make serving on the leadership committee an exclusive, high-profile activity. They tend to spend so much time focusing on getting only the cream of the crop leaders that they end up leaving other, lower-profile leaders behind. The key is to find people who can help—and as many as possible. You don't want everyone on your committee, but getting enough so you can personally reach every possible philanthropic source is important.

Campaign leaders should be committed to the success of the campaign and have knowledge of the mission of the organization and how that organization serves the community. Ideally, the campaign leader will also make a leadership gift.

A leadership gift is not always, but often is, judged by the size of the gift. A leadership gift is one that provides leadership by its amount and timing. That may mean a leader could make a $10,000 gift if a $10,000 gift would impress other potential leaders. If the leader you are recruiting is a multi-millionaire or independently wealthy (or is perceived in the community to be super wealthy), then a $10,000 gift is not going to impress anyone. Making the gift when it will do the most good for the campaign, say early in the campaign, is often as valuable as the amount of the gift.

The key here is to find someone that is truly committed—with both time and money—to the campaign. In addition to the gift, the leader should be willing to allow his/her name to be used in recruiting and soliciting others.

The most important contribution of great leaders is their willingness to open doors to other potential leaders and donors. Having the right person ask is almost always THE critical part of the campaign process. The campaign leader should be highly respected and someone that others will welcome into their homes or offices and to whom they will listen. If a proposed leader can't, or won't, open the door to potential leaders and donors, then that person is not a leader ... he/she is a donor.

Campaign leadership can come from a variety of sources including:

  • Past Board Members
  • Volunteers
  • Community Leaders
  • Corporate Leaders
  • Board Members
  • Elected Officials
  • Current Board Members
  • Industry Leaders

A great source of campaign leaders is from previously successful campaigns in the community. Review past campaigns and seek the involvement of those leaders in your campaign.

Recruiting campaign leaders is a relatively straightforward process. The challenge usually comes out of a fear of actually doing it. Together with board members and/or other key leaders, a list of potential leaders should be created. These leaders should consist of the best leaders imaginable in the community—and should include any past donors, leaders, or volunteers for your organization.

Once the list is developed, then it is as simple as identifying a current leader of the organization who will set up an appointment.

You can involve new leaders in campaigns by asking them to do three things, and promising them one thing:

Ask them to allow you to use their names as supporters. Then create a growing list of these leaders. Once you have a few well-respected leaders, you'll probably find that other leaders will choose to be leaders as well. As you recruit a leader, tell other potential leaders about your past recruitment successes.

Ask them to open doors to other prospective leaders. Explain that you would like to return and meet with them again to ask their guidance in reviewing other prospects and seek their help in arranging meetings with a pre-determined number of prospects, usually five. This limits the time they are involved with your campaign, yet allows them to be a big part of it.

Ask them to make a financial gift. Ultimately, fundraising is what it is about, so you have to ask for a specific gift.

Tell them that they will not have to come to committee meetings. Community leaders hate committee meetings—especially meetings that drag on and don't accomplish any tangible goals. Explain to the potential leader that whatever time he/she can spend on the campaign will be spent doing the one thing the organization can't do without people like him/her—opening doors to other potential leaders and donors.

William C. Krueger, Capital Quest, Inc.
© 2011, Capital Quest, Inc. Reprinted from Contributions Magazine, vol. 25, no. 3; reprinted with permission.

who-will-lead-your-fundraising-campaign_William-Krueger.jpgWilliam C. Krueger is founder and CEO of Capital Quest, Inc., a 20-year-old national capital campaign consulting firm. He has spent close to 25 years in the capital campaign consulting firm and works with a variety of nonprofits including health care, social service, religious, education, and community organizations.

Topics: Fundraising